Skip to Content

5 on Friday: Columbus Donuts

It goes without saying that these local donut shops are kid-tested and approved! 😉 (Has a kid ever met a donut he didn’t approve of?) I’ll be honest, I’ve only recently cared about donuts. I think that’s because, for a long time, my experience was limited to chains. Only in the past few years have I had some donuts that have caused me to think about them later and even crave them! There are so MANY great choices for donuts these days (I envision a Part 2 in the not-to-distant future), but here are 5 that have received our two thumbs up!

1. DK Diner, Grandview Heights

1715 W 3rd Ave, Columbus, OH 43212, 614-488-5160

DK Diner was maker of the first donut I craved – the sour cream donut! 😋 Chocolate is really good, too! Of course, my kids always pick the donuts with the sprinkles. If you didn’t know, DK stands for Donut Kitchen and donuts were the first and only thing sold at the beginning of DK diner!

2. Destination Donuts, Downtown

59 Spruce St., Columbus OH 43215, 614-525-0878

Destination Donut has some really fun options! How about White Chocolate Pretzel and Salty Caramel or Aztec Chocolate and Spiced Pepitas? (Jaden chose Vanilla. Haha.) These are a bit more pricey than the others listed here so it’s a decadent treat! Flavors change daily and besides the stall at North Market, they can also be found at these locations!

3. Schneider’s Bakery, Westerville

Schneider’s is a long standing Westerville tradition, opening at 1:30 AM most days for your donut cravings! Only here can you get a 10″ Celebration Donut (think of this as a replacement to the birthday cake!) Cash or check only here and most of the donuts are just $.75 or $.85!

4. Amy’s Donuts, West Side

There are so many choices at Amy’s Donuts it can almost be overwhelming! For instance trying choosing 18 different donuts on a Saturday morning at 8:45 AM when there’s a line nearly out the door waiting behind you! No pressure! I’m not trying to scare you off because you should definitely try these if you haven’t already! SO good! I love the old fashioned varieties here and, of course, my kids love the crazy candy combinations! You can also schedule a tour, which is a fun outing with the kids!  Spoiler Alert: they get to decorate their own donuts at the end! 😉

5. Jolly Pirate Donuts, Grove City

3118 Southwest Blvd., Grove City, OH 43123, 614-871-1070

Jolly Pirate is your classic donut shop! There are two locations in the Columbus area: Grove City and Reynoldsburg. The Grove City location (where these pictures were taken) closed briefly but is back open under new ownership!  There are a lot of fancy donut shops to choose from, but if you want a classic donut and coffee experience this is it! No frills, good donuts!

What’s your favorite Columbus donut shop?

IMG_8735

Make sure to follow What Should We Do Today? on FacebookTwitterPinterest and Instagram and never miss a post!

ICYMI: What Should We Do This Weekend? April 14-16, 2017 Easter Edition!

5 Super Fun Playgrounds in Grove City

Saturday 5th of August 2023

[…] These 5 parks in Grove City are super fun and very unique! If you’re looking to round out your trip to one of these playgrounds try out Transcend Coffee in Grove City Town Center or a good old fashioned donut stop at Jolly Pirate Donuts! […]

Lydia

Tuesday 25th of April 2017

I need to try some of these donut shops. Thanks for posting! Buckeye Donuts on High St by OSU campus has delicious donuts, and some great flavor options. They also have donuts with sprinkles, which is a necessity for my daughter when eating donuts.

Julie Miller

Tuesday 25th of April 2017

You're welcome! We haven't been to Buckeye Donuts but I have heard they are good! My kids ALWAYS pick the ones with sprinkles! :)